I have been trying for quite sometime now to make a re-entry to blogging and when Mrunal came up with this new blog idea, I decided it was time. Being my first guest post, I will stick to the one subject I love the most – Cricket.

Cricket versus T20

Along with over-arm bowling, Kerry Packer and the third umpire, T20 will undoubtedly go down in history as one of the few things that changed the game forever. Like all those changes, the impact of T20 was not immediate – Two years and an Indian win in the inaugural World cup was what it took to capture India’s, and thus, the cricketing world’s, imagination. Smartly, Lalit Modi & Co stepped in. A few cash-rich corporates, some of the world’s best players, a borrowed concept and a booming economy (on second thoughts, just a growing economy) took care of the rest. No one even remembers poor Subash Chandra now.

Well, with IPL2 ready to rock South African audiences and Indian televisions, I thought about why IPL1 didn’t fascinate me as much as it should have. Surely, if not for all the glitz and glamour, atleast the big names and the cricket on display should have had me. First and foremost, I guess it was the city-based teams’ concept. I really didn’t feel that passionate about supporting my city, or any city for that matter. And when Mathew Hayden, Joginder Sharma and Andy Morkel turn out for Chennai SuperKings, whatever little you felt is also gone. On the other hand, when Team India is playing, it’s a totally different ball game. The ecstasy that an Indian win brings is truly unmatched and so is the disappointment at a narrow loss.

The second thing that doesn’t work for me is the whole T20 concept itself. Sure, it gets over in three hours and fits television audiences perfectly but for a serious cricket fan, the cricket on view is not as pleasing as Test or one-day cricket. I remember seeing the inaugural T20 WC and truth be told, I fell for it. What nail-biting excitement it provided and of course, India kept winning. Two years on, the format has not evolved as much as it should have with the result that we keep seeing batsmen trying to hit every ball for a six. Swing and seam are gone; Flight and loop have been forgotten and it’s all about getting the Yorker length.

There is no doubt that T20 has given an exciting twist to the gentleman’s game. As Richie Benaud famously remarked “Test cricket is what parents take their kids to and T20 is what kids bring their parents to” (or some such thing). It has got a whole new generation of people hooked onto cricket. It has got more money into the game and for a cash-strapped ICC, it’s a huge opportunity. But let this opportunity not lead us to the demise of the game. Let it not turn cricket into some fast-paced action thriller where power and purpose take control over skill and strategy. The Dhonis and Gambhirs of today were brought up on Sachin’s Sharjah-like innings. Let Yuvaraj’s six sixes in an over not be the role model for tomorrow’s cricketing princes. Let T20 be what it is - the fun-filled, relaxed form of the game.

It’s a tribute to the game that Test cricket is still considered the pinnacle by its players and fans. And it’s a tribute to its administrators that they have maintained the balance between all the three formats. Undoubtedly, the big challenge will be to sustain the same in the coming years. Let’s maintain IPL as what it is – a cleverly packaged entertainment show with cricket as its anchor. Let it stay as the format where Buchnan tries out his multi-captaincy theories and Modi his time-out commercials. But let’s not take it beyond that.
Labels: edit post
5 Responses
  1. Mrunalini Says:

    For someone who is a not a cricket fan, T 20 sounds more fun - get done with it in 3 hrs :)


  2. M B Mahesh Says:

    Vimal macha....vandhutuya....Your passion when you write on any subject is what makes your blog extremely interesting...waiting for something more...and not just a few liners that it is olympics time and passion

    Imagine that your fathers would have been saying the same thing about one dayers :P....It is a losing battle that you seem to having.I think it is better to have test matches to test the skills of the batsmen and bowlers and T20.

    However, one thing is sure T20 is here to stay...Test will die soon while one dayers will take some more time.

    Hail Vimal for making his entry back...If you want ..can ask a few more ppl on campus to motivate you to restart writing.


  3. Shreyan M L Says:

    T20 rocks .. Test matches were v boring ..ODIs were fun only in first 15 overs and last 10 overs .. now bring the two together .. you have T20 .. aligning more with spectator interest .. i think -ve 1 run should be introduced for every dot ball .. well written post my boy .. though i dont agree that T20 is bad .. it mite just save the game of cricket from being restricted to just being played one country in the world :)


  4. Vimal Says:

    @Mrunal - Exactly my point. It has definitely helped the game reach a wider audience - no doubt abt that.

    @Mahesh - Thanks.
    Iam not so sure whether Tests will die that easily. I beleive one-dayers will probably be the first format to get affected because of T20. In the long run, if T20 really becomes the only form of cricket, I dont think its good for the game.

    @Shreyan - Test matches can be boring when the opposing sides are unbalanced and the pitches don't have anything to offer(which is the case with one-dayers and T20 as well). But test series in the last couple of years have been of extremely high quality - i believe we should reduce the number of test playing teams to six so that the quality and interest is maintained in the game. We can always use one-dayers and T20 to develop the game in new countries.

    @All - I never said T20 is bad. Its just that its not the best format of the game. The game has a certain charm to it - building partnerships, bowling good spells, strategising the next move- all these are completely lost in this format. Though it might be very successful, it can never be the best.


  5. Anonymous Says:

    Welcome back to the keyboard, Vimal. This is the age of instant gratification; I dont see T20 dying away anytime soon.

    Only time will tell if all genuine cricket lovers share your sentiments.

    And how many more people are you waiting for, to ask you to continue writing again?


Post a Comment